“The countries that were big winners will be the hardest hit” says expert Ernesto Talvi
The Uruguayan economy is passing through an exceptional moment: there is strong economic growth, drastically falling unemployment and a historic reduction in the level of poverty. This is not just the scenario in Uruguay; it is the scenario in all the countries categorized as “dynamic emerging markets”. It is not even unique in Uruguay’s history: it has happened before and it has never ended well.
This is how the academic director for the Center for Current Economic and Social Studies (CERES), Ernesto Talvi, referred to the current economic situation at a conference titled “The Global Economy, the Region, and Uruguay: Where are we now and what can we expect?” which took place yesterday at the Club de Golf.
According to the expert, Uruguay and the region are exposed to external conditions. A bad ending to the European debt crisis would expose Uruguay’s weaknesses as well as those of neighboring countries. “The hardest hit will be those [businesses] that gained the most” from weaker developed economies, the influx of cheap capital, and increasing demand for Uruguayan exports, he explained.
Vulnerabilities
The principal weakness detected by CERES is the structural imbalance in the public accounts. The latest Economy Ministry estimates show a fiscal deficit through March equivalent to 2.7% of GDP. However, considering the state’s income potential, and taking into account sustainable longterm economic growth levels, Talvi predicts that the deficit will shoot up to 6.1% of GDP.
“These silver sweet periods of high commodity prices are periods of euphoria, of exuberance, and a great sensation of wellbeing. We begin to think there is something good that we are doing now that we weren’t doing before” said Talvi.
He compared the effects of Lehman’s collapse with other earlier crises that had produced similar results in the region.
With regards to economic growth, currency exchange, inflation, public spending and poverty; the countries in the region behaved similarly during different periods of capital influx. One example is that in the exchange market, large depreciations against the dollar coincide with periods of large capital inflows.
Talvi explained that Uruguay “is pretty much aligned with the rest of the region” in terms of exchange rates. He added that “the largest devaluations are produced when there is strong misalignment” in the region and which he assured “is not the case today”.
The worst case scenario
If the euro falls apart and as a repercussion emerging countries have a liquidity problem, the period of abundant capital in the region will come to an end. And like in all the previous examples, it will have un desired consequences for Uruguay and the region, he explained.
In the past, 93% of the countries that had massive capital inflows eventually had to face a severe reversal in those flows. As a result economic activity in 69% of those was strongly affected and 77% faced severe depreciation. Additionally, 49% suffered banking crises and 33% were forced to restructure their debt. In fact 17% of these countries ended with a “quadruple crisis”. One of these was Uruguay. Talvi explained that today, before there is a reversal in the flow of investments, the country should correct its level of government spending and its exchange rate, but does not need to make changes to the banking system or public debt. “This is good news” he emphasized “a crisis in the those two can really kill countries”.
This Uruguay Business Reports article is a translation of a news story which appeared in the Uruguayan newspaper El Observador. That article, in Spanish, is available here. Uruguay Business Reports news translation by Donovan Carberry.