Electroingeniería lacks the experience for the project
UTE, Uruguay’s state power company, has decided to reject Electoingeniería’s bid to construct a combined cycle power plant in San José because it did not meet the state requirements. The news was an “absolute surprise” to Electroingeniería. Hyundi HDEC’s bid is UTE’s new preliminary selection.
After a month of analysis, UTE’s technical commission decided to reject the Argentinean firm’s bid to construct the combined cycle power plant in Punta del Tigre, San José. Electroingeniería’s bid was UTE’s preliminary selection because it was the lowest cost bid entered.
UTE’s board of directors voted unanimously to reject Electroingeniería’s bid. The technical comission’s report had advised, “electroingeniería has not met the capacity and experience requirements of this tender, since they were never the principal contractor in the background history they presented”. The board of directors concluded “we reserve the exclusive right to judgment [on the contract] and definitively rescind acceptance of this offer”.
The Partido National’s UTE board member, Enrique Antía, told El País that the technical commission’s criticism of the company’s background “was overwhelming” . He stressed that the board’s issue “was not technical problems”.
The UTE lawyers closely investigating Electroingenería’s work history warned the technical commission that the Argentinean company had no experience as a contractor and therefore could not be put in charge of a project requiring a $500 million USD investment and which would eventually produce 580MW, close to half of all Uruguay’s electrical usage.
Mr. Antía, speaking on the board’s decision said “it was not a surprise. There was always a strong belief that technically Electroingeniería was not the best [company] to award UTE’s contract to”.
The Argentinean firm said that the decision was received “absolute surprise, given that our offer is the best technically and economically [it was the lowest bid at $531 million USD], it saves the country $78 million USD”.
Although Electroingeniería admitted that the tender “is a process regulated by Uruguay’s public law”, the business confirmed that they did not know the reasons they were rejected and they “hope to learn the details of the decision so [they] can evaluate the next steps”.
The other firms which participated in the tender speculated the reason Electroingeniería’s bid was rejected was the lower capacity of their proposed turbines. However, the UTE’s board of directors dismissed these claims.
Hyundai HDEC’s bid is now UTE’s preliminary selection
With Electroingenería’s bid rejected, the Korean company Hyundai HDEC is now the preliminary winner. Hyundai HEDC should not be confused with Hyundai HEC, who was barred from the tender after they falsified the work history they presented to UTE.
Hyundai HDEC must present all the technical documentation on their proposed turbines and their previous experience with this type of contract by Wednesday, October 3rd. Once Hyundai HDEC has presented all the documentation, the technical commission has 20 days to study it and evaluate the company’s ability to construct the first combined cycle power plant in Uruguay.
Mr. Antía declared that Hyundai HDEC “has a solid history of constructing power plants with similar characteristics”. However he also stressed that “[the board] is going to review all the information to learn if the company will comply with everything before we sign the contract.”
This Uruguay Business Reports news article is a translation of an article that appeared in the Uruguayan newspaper El País. The original Spanish language article is available here. Uruguay Business Reports translation by Donovan Carberry.